Unfair Dismissal case review

Last updated: August 10th, 2023

Background

The employee was employed for 13 years as a contract cleaner in a Storehouse until her dismissal for gross misconduct in 2014. The contract cleaning company was responsible for the general cleaning of the storehouse building in question where the employee was employed as a cleaner.

Employers Case

The cleaning company told the tribunal how they were contacted on the night in question and were informed that a serious incident had occurred at a Storehouse where a function of 360 people was taking place. The employer gave evidence that they investigated the incident and interviewed the employee with the right to representation at the meeting. The alleged incident was that the employee had used the executive suite for her break and while using the toaster, a piece of bread got stuck which activated the fire alarm. The employer described to the tribunal that the alarm system has a pre warning system which last for 2-5 minutes, the system allows for the alarm system to be de –activated before it goes into full evacuation mode. During the investigation they established that the employee panicked and ran from the executive suite thus allowing the alarm system to become fully activated. The employee also stated during the investigation she was afraid to report the incident to management. The alarm was subsequently stopped by a manager before the building was evacuated, and the evacuation process did not actually commence. Following the conclusion of the investigation the investigation officer recommended that the claimant be suspended pending further investigation. The matter then progressed to a disciplinary hearing.

During the investigation the employee stated she was very remorseful for her actions. The employee stated within the minutes that she did not have permission to access the executive suite but she did not like taking her break in the staff cabin as it was untidy. The employer found the allegations amounted to gross misconduct in accordance with the disciplinary rules.

Employee’s case

The employee told the tribunal that staff always took their breaks in the executive suite for breaks, including breaks with Supervisors and with Managers. She was never told she could not take her break there. On the night in question, the employee said she owned up to what happened as she felt if she took the blame she would just get a slap on the hands because of her service record. The claimant did not receive any training in relation to the alarm or evacuation procedures.

Tribunal decision

The Employment Appeals Tribunal found that the dismissal was unfair by reason that the respondent knew or ought to have known that the claimant and other staff used the suite for their breaks and practice and procedure condoned by the supervisors and or Managers had allowed them to do so.

The tribunal awarded €25,000 in compensation to the employee.

Lessons to learn from this case

This case highlights the importance of the sanction fitting the misconduct. As an employer if you are skipping steps in your disciplinary procedure or going straight to dismissal by way of gross misconduct, the alleged misconduct must be serious enough and justify the dismissal or the higher sanction.

Another important lesson is to ensure you have clear policies and procedures in place, the reasons for dismissal was that the employee did not follow procedure, however the employee stated that she did not have training on the procedure. If you have procedures that could potentially lead to a formal sanction, you have to train employees, have written confirmation that they received training and understand the training and also have a policy in place.

In any unfair dismissal case, the tribunal will look at the process and was there a justifiable reason for this employee to lose their job. There did seem to be fair process applied in this case, namely right to representation, investigation, disciplinary hearing and right of appeal however the tribunal ultimately found that the employee did not deserve to lose her job over this incident.

Always get advice if considering a dismissal our advice line can help you on 01 8860350

Book a call with a consultant

Complete the form below and a consultant will call you as soon as possible.

Book a call with a consultant

Complete the form below and a consultant will call you as soon as possible.

Latest Resources

Seasonal workers: what employers should know

Seasonal workers
As the days get longer and the skies get sunnier (well, sometimes), summer is on people’s minds. This means that business owners, meanwhile, are starting […]

St Patrick’s Day: Have you prepared for absenteeism?

Published: March 20th 2024 Following national celebrations and public holidays like St Patrick’s day, you could find yourself down several staff members. And – as […]

What Employees Are Entitled to a Public Holiday Benefit & How Are Benefits Calculated?

public holiday
Published: March 20th 2024 From Easter Monday to St Patrick’s Day, Ireland gets ten public holidays and, with them, public holiday benefits. But what if […]

Olga Shevchenko

Director/Advocate, Immigration Advice Bureau

Olga Shevchenko specialises in immigration advocacy and consultancy, in particular, employment permit, visas, family reunification, citizenship, etc, for those seeking to visit, reside or invest in Ireland.

Olga provides extensive information, knowledge, and support to her clients, enabling access to positive solutions for people struggling to handle the immigration law.

Minister Neale Richmond

Minister of State, Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment

Neale Richmond TD was appointed as Minister of State at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment with special responsibility for Employment Affairs and Retail Business and the Department of Social Protection in January 2023.

Much of his work at the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment is with businesses, workers, their representative bodies and the State Agencies to ensure that the economic recovery and growth extends to all parts of the country. He works closely with the SME sector, including retail, on building resilience and on the transition to the green and digital economies.

Mark Carpenter

Director of Regulatory & Corporate Affairs, Sky

Mark Carpenter is Director of Regulatory & Corporate Affairs at Sky Ireland. In this role he has responsibility for External and Internal Communications, Public Policy and Regulatory Affairs and the company’s ‘Bigger Picture’ (CSR) programme. He also works closely with Sky Group teams on a variety of matters, in particular our partnerships with domestic broadcasters.

Prior to working at Sky, Mark worked as a Policy Officer in Houses of the Oireachtas and as a Management Consultant at Accenture. He has a BA in History from Oxford University and a PhD in Political Science from Trinity College Dublin.

Nora Cashe

Litigation and Compliance Manager, Peninsula

Nóra studied Law in Griffith College Dublin and qualified as a Barrister in 2008, practising in the area of Criminal law. She is also member of the Irish Employment Law Association.

Nora has extensive experience representing clients at Employment Tribunal hearings, Conciliation / Mediation meetings before both the Workplace Relations Commission and the Labour Court. 

Nóra is a member of the Irish Employment Law Association and engages with the WRC Adjudication Service as part of their stakeholder engagement forum.

Deiric McCann

Managing Director, Genos International Europe

Deiric McCann leads Genos International Europe – The EU division of a world-leading provider of emotional intelligence solutions. 

With over two decades experience at the highest levels of management, Deiric supports clients to develop the resilience, emotional intelligence, psychological safety and engagements of their employees.

Rhiannon Coyne

Senior HR Consultant, Graphite HRM

Rhiannon Coyne is a Senior HR Consultant at Graphite HRM and will be providing an overview of best practice on how to deal with complaints of bullying and harassment in the workplace. 

With a number of recent updates to employment laws, Rhiannon will take a closer look at employment equality and how it is interlinked to Health & Safety and what employers can learn from recent case laws.

David Begg

Chairman, Workplace Relations Commission

David Begg was appointed Chairperson of the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) in January 2021.

David is also a professor at Maynooth University Institute of Social Sciences. Mr Begg’s extensive history in the trade union movement included leading the ESB Officers Association and Irish Congress of Trade Unions, stepping away from the latter in 2001 to chair international aid agency Concern.

David Begg was also previously a director of the Central Bank of Ireland between 1995 and 2010.